Part Location Diagram of 2165091 Coleman Leather Pump Cup
See part A-8 in the diagram
( Grid squares measure 1x1 inch )

Leather Pump Cup 2165091

Manufactured by:
Coleman
ERP Number:
ERP17016716
Part Number:
2165091
Original Equipment Manufacturer ?
  Works with your model  505A!
In Stock
Delivers in 3-5 Business Days!

Easy 

15 - 30 mins 

(18 rated repairs) ?
  Works with your model   505A!

Product Description

?

This genuine Coleman replacement part is designed for use with select lanterns and stoves. Made from high-quality leather, this pump cup fits securely at the end of the pump plunger, creating an airtight seal that’s essential for proper pressure buildup and reliable operation. Over time, leather pump cups can dry out, crack, or harden, which can reduce performance or prevent your equipment from functioning altogether. If you notice difficulty building pressure or visible wear on the cup, it’s time for a replacement. This part is sold individually and installs easily—no tools required. For best results, keep the leather lightly oiled to maintain flexibility and extend its lifespan.

Frequently Purchased Together

?

Troubleshooting

This part works with the following brands:
  • Coleman
This part works with the following products:
  • Lighting
  • Camping Equipment
Part# 2165091 replaces these:
216-5091,
★

Customer Part Reviews

?
4.3
Average Rating (out of 5):
★★★★★
★★★★★
(3 Reviews)
Click to filter by ratings:
  • 5 stars
    2
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    1
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 star
    0
  • 1
Sort by:  
Sorry, we couldn't find any existing reviews that matched. Try using some different or simpler keywords.

Customer Repair Instructions

All our customer repair instructions are solicited directly from other customers just like you who have purchased and replaced this exact part.

Easy 

15 - 30 mins 

(18 rated repairs) ?
  • 1
  • 2
Sort by:  
Sorry, we couldn't find any existing installation instruction that matched.

Leather gasket was worn out in Coleman stove fuel pump.

Jeanie from Carlsbad, New Mexico

11 of 11 people found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
Less than 15 mins
Tools:
Screw drivers
Parts Used:
2165091
Used a small flat blade screwdriver to take wire clip out of the hole, pulled the plunger out of the sleeve. Then, used a screwdriver to bend back ears of the washer. Removed the old leather seal, replaced with the new seal, put the washer back in place on the plunger. added drop of motor oil to new leather. Installed the plunger in the s leeve and fastened the wire clip back in the hole. Less than 10 minutes.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Coleman model 413E gas camp cook stove was acting up with high yellow flames instead of small blue flames

J from Doyle, California

8 of 8 people found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
15 - 30 mins
Tools:
Pliers, Screw drivers, Wrench (Adjustable), Wrench set
Pulled clip from fuel tank at the plunger and installed new parts with some oil on the new leather cup. Unscrewed valve and Generator assy. and applied sealer to threads on new assembly, and tightened then screwed on the new cap. Pumped it up and it works like it did new in 1956.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Needed new cap generator and general cleaning

mike from tucson, Arizona

3 of 3 people found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
30 - 60 mins
Tools:
Screw drivers, Wrench set
First of all I have a two burner Coleman stove,made in 1964. With the parts I purchased here,and performed quite well on my camping trip. Lantern worked well. Told my friends about this site. Thanks again.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Pump on lantern needed a new leather cup.

Charles from Phoenix, Arizona

2 of 2 people found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
Less than 15 mins
Tools:
Screw drivers
Parts Used:
2165091, 3000004345
Removed the pump clip with a screw driver removed the pump, removed the retaining clip for the cup removed old cup reversed the procedure and reinstalled, very easy
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Coleman 426D 3 burner stove did not burn correctly

Brian from Delafield, Wisconsin

2 of 2 people found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
30 - 60 mins
Tools:
Pliers, Screw drivers, Wrench (Adjustable)
Parts Used:
2165091, 2006381ZCL
1) Replaced leather plunger. Simply remove clip on plunger with a needle nose. Pull the plunger out. Leather plunger is either held on by a clip or a nut. Remove and replace.
2) Replaced main valve and generator. This is sold as a single part. Drain the fuel tank. Unscrew valve from tank. Screw in new one. I did use gas resis tant Teflon tape on the threads.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

The original leather pump cup was bad in a Coleman fuel lantern I paid $12 for.

warren from dansville , New York

2 of 2 people found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
Less than 15 mins
Parts Used:
2165091
I simply replaced the leather gasket.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Coleman lantern would not stay lit

Patrick from GENESEO, Illinois

2 of 2 people found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
Less than 15 mins
Tools:
Wrench (Adjustable)
Parts Used:
2421071, 2165091, 3000005090
Watched repair on U-TUBE of vintage Coleman lanterns. Followed instructions on package of new generator. Replaced leather pump cup.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Filler cap gasket leaking

Don from Monmouth, Oregon

1 person found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
Less than 15 mins
Tools:
Screw drivers
Parts Used:
2165091, 3000005086
Replaced filler cap on old Coleman stove
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Fuel tanks would not hold pressure, leaking back through check valve

Howard from MILTON FREEWATER, Oregon

1 person found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
30 - 60 mins
Tools:
Pliers, Screw drivers
Parts Used:
2165091, 2006381ZCL
Simple replacement on leather cups, the check valve and stem were pretty straight forward, there is a tool for check valve replacement. I used extruder the size of hole in check valve.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!

Leather seal on Coleman camp stove air pump dried and cracked.

Ronald from Leland, North Carolina

1 person found this instruction helpful.
Difficulty Level:
Easy
Total Repair Time:
Less than 15 mins
Tools:
Pliers, Wrench (Adjustable)
Parts Used:
2165091
Remove air pump from fuel tank.
Remove old seal from pump stem.
Note fastener orientation.
Soak new plunger in oil overnight
Reassemble pump stem.
Reinstall pump stem into fuel tank.
Careful, it is easy to damage the new, swollen seal.
Test the new pump.
Did you find this story helpful?
Thank you for voting!
  • 1
  • 2

Model Cross Reference

This part works with the following models:
ERP Number: ERP17016716
Manufacturer Part Number: 2165091
Brand Model Number Description
Coleman 200A195 Lighting - 1-Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 200A700 Lighting - 1-Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 201-700 Lighting - Kerosene Lantern
Coleman 201-7009 Lighting - Kerosene Lantern
Coleman 202 Lighting - Single Mantle Lantern
Coleman 206-703 Lighting - Kerosene Lantern
Coleman 220F195 Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 220H195 Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 220J195 Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 220K195 Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 228D Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 228E Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 228F195 Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 228H195 Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 228J195 Lighting - 275-710 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 22E197 Lighting - 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 234 Lighting - Single Mantle Kerosene Lantern
Coleman 237-195 Lighting - Kerosene Single-Mantle Lantern
Coleman 237A195 Lighting - Kerosene Single-Mantle Lantern
Coleman 237B195 Lighting - Kerosene Single-Mantle Lantern
Coleman 242C Lighting - Single Mantle Propane Lantern
Coleman 243 Lighting - Instant Lite Lantern
Coleman 243A Lighting - Instant Lite Lantern
Coleman 275-710 Lighting - 275A710 2 Mantle Gas Lantern
Coleman 413E Camping Equipment - Fuel Stove
Coleman 413F Camping Equipment - Fuel Stove
Coleman 413G499 Camping Equipment - 2-Burner Gas Camp Stove
Coleman 413H499 Camping Equipment - 2 Burner Gas Camp Stove
Coleman 425E499 Camping Equipment - 2 Burner Gas Camp Stove
Coleman 426D499 Camping Equipment - 3 Burner Gas Camp Stove